Methodology. (Last update: 6/25/24)
| Rank | Player | Position | Years |
| 1 | Wayne Gretzky | C | 1978-1999 |
| 2 | Gordie Howe | RW | 1946-1980 |
| 3 | Alexander Ovechkin | LW | 2005-active |
| 4 | Mario Lemieux | C | 1984-2006 |
| 5 | Bobby Orr | D | 1966-1979 |
| 6 | Sidney Crosby | C | 2005-active |
| 7 | Patrick Roy | G | 1984-2003 |
| 8 | Connor McDavid | C | 2015-active |
| 9 | Jaromir Jagr | RW | 1990-2018 |
| 10 | Mark Messier | C | 1978-2004 |
| 11 | Martin Brodeur | G | 1991-2015 |
| 12 | Phil Esposito | C | 1963-1981 |
| 13 | Nicklas Lidstrom | D | 1991-2012 |
| 14 | Ray Bourque | D | 1979-2001 |
| 15 | Dominik Hasek | G | 1990-2008 |
| 16 | Jean Beliveau | C | 1950-1971 |
| 17 | Bobby Hull | LW | 1957-1980 |
| 18 | Maurice Richard | RW | 1942-1960 |
| 19 | Guy Lafleur | RW | 1971-1991 |
| 20 | Doug Harvey | D | 1947-1969 |
| 21 | Jacques Plante | G | 1952-1975 |
| 22 | Ken Dryden | G | 1970-1979 |
| 23 | Glen Hall | G | 1952-1971 |
| 24 | Stan Mikita | C | 1958-1980 |
| 25 | Bobby Clarke | C | 1969-1984 |
| 26 | Evgeni Malkin | C | 2006-active |
| 27 | Eddie Shore | D | 1926-1940 |
| 28 | Joe Sakic | C | 1988-2009 |
| 29 | Patrick Kane | RW | 2007-active |
| 30 | Nikita Kucherov | RW | 2013-active |
| 31 | Steve Yzerman | C | 1983-2006 |
| 32 | Bryan Trottier | C | 1975-1994 |
| 33 | Brett Hull | RW | 1986-2006 |
| 34 | Erik Karlsson | D | 2009-active |
| 35 | Paul Coffey | D | 1980-2001 |
| 36 | Chris Chelios | D | 1983-2010 |
| 37 | Denis Potvin | D | 1973-1988 |
| 38 | Andrei Vasilevskiy | G | 2014-active |
| 39 | Mike Bossy | RW | 1977-1987 |
| 40 | Howie Morenz | C | 1923-1937 |
| 41 | Terry Sawchuk | G | 1949-1970 |
| 42 | Al MacInnis | D | 1981-2004 |
| 43 | Larry Robinson | D | 1972-1992 |
| 44 | Jari Kurri | RW | 1978-1998 |
| 45 | Nathan MacKinnon | C | 2013-active |
| 46 | Red Kelly | D/C | 1947-1967 |
| 47 | Pierre Pilote | D | 1955-1969 |
| 48 | Sergei Fedorov | C | 1990-2009 |
| 49 | Peter Forsberg | C | 1994-2011 |
| 50 | Patrice Bergeron | C | 2003-2023 |
| 51 | Auston Matthews | C | 2016-active |
| 52 | Leon Draisaitl | C | 2014-active |
| 53 | Chris Pronger | D | 1993-2012 |
| 54 | Brian Leetch | D | 1987-2006 |
| 55 | Cyclone Taylor | R | 1905-1923 |
| 56 | Newsy Lalonde | C | 1917-1927 |
| 57 | Joe Malone | C/LW | 1917-1924 |
| 58 | Teemu Selanne | RW | 1992-2014 |
| 59 | Scott Stevens | D | 1982-2004 |
| 60 | Jarome Iginla | RW | 1996-2017 |
| 61 | Steve Stamkos | C | 2008-active |
| 62 | Ed Belfour | G | 1988-2007 |
| 63 | Ted Lindsay | LW | 1944-1965 |
| 64 | Marcel Dionne | C | 1971-1989 |
| 65 | Scott Niedermayer | D | 1991-2010 |
| 66 | Zdeno Chara | D | 1997-2022 |
| 67 | Duncan Keith | D | 2005-2022 |
| 68 | Anze Kopitar | C | 2006-active |
| 69 | Brad Park | D | 1968-1985 |
| 70 | Bernie Geoffrion | RW | 1950-1968 |
| 71 | Bernie Parent | G | 1965-1979 |
| 72 | Bill Durnan | G | 1943-1950 |
| 73 | Joe Thornton | C | 1997-2022 |
| 74 | Doug Gilmour | C | 1983-2003 |
| 75 | Ted Kennedy | C | 1942-1957 |
| 76 | Drew Doughty | D | 2008-active |
| 77 | Tony Esposito | G | 1968-1984 |
| 78 | Frank Mahovlich | LW | 1956-1978 |
| 79 | Nels Stewart | C | 1925-1940 |
| 80 | Elmer Lach | C | 1940-1954 |
| 81 | Henrik Lundqvist | G | 2005-2020 |
| 82 | Sergei Bobrovsky | G | 2010-active |
| 83 | Pavel Datsyuk | C | 2001-2016 |
| 84 | Martin St. Louis | RW | 1998-2015 |
| 85 | Eric Lindros | C | 1992-2007 |
| 86 | Ron Francis | C | 1981-2004 |
| 87 | Billy Smith | G | 1971-1989 |
| 88 | Luc Robitaille | LW | 1986-2003 |
| 89 | Roberto Luongo | G | 1999-2019 |
| 90 | Tim Thomas | G | 2002-2014 |
| 91 | Rod Langaway | D | 1977-1993 |
| 92 | Dickie Moore | LW | 1951-1968 |
| 93 | Pavel Bure | RW | 1991-2003 |
| 94 | Andy Bathgate | RW | 1952-1975 |
| 95 | Johnny Bower | G | 1953-1970 |
| 96 | Milt Schmidt | C/D | 1936-1955 |
| 97 | Syl Apps | C | 1936-1948 |
| 98 | Bill Cook | RW | 1926-1937 |
| 99 | Frank Nighbor | C | 1917-1930 |
| 100 | Charlie Conacher | W | 1929-1941 |